Teething is one of the biggest milestones in your baby’s first year — but it often comes with drool, fussiness, and sore gums. The right teething toy can make all the difference by providing soothing relief, sensory stimulation, and safe chewing options.
In this guide, we’ll explore the best teething toys for babies, safety tips from pediatric experts, and how to choose the perfect teether for your little one. All picks are non-toxic, BPA-free, and parent-approved.
Table of Contents
🔍 Why Trust Our List
We researched top-rated baby teething toys from trusted brands, analyzed pediatric recommendations, and checked recent product recalls to ensure safety. Each toy was selected for:
- Safe, non-toxic materials (food-grade silicone or natural rubber)
- Ease of cleaning and durability
- Positive parent reviews and pediatrician recommendations
- Availability and value
⭐ Best Teething Toys: Quick Top Picks (Updated)
Let’s explore deeper into the best Teething Toys you can consider for your baby.
🐘 1. Comotomo Silicone Baby Teether — Best Overall
Why we love it:
Comotomo’s teether is soft, flexible, and designed for little hands to grasp easily. Made from medical-grade silicone, it’s dishwasher safe and perfectly textured to massage sore gums.
Pros:
✅ Safe, BPA-free, and easy to sterilize
✅ Four different arms for baby to bite and hold
✅ Durable and hygienic one-piece design
🦒 2. Sophie la Girafe — Best Natural Rubber Teether
A long-time favorite among parents, Sophie la Girafe is made from 100% natural Hevea rubber and painted with food-grade dyes. Its lightweight body and squeaky sound stimulate touch and hearing.
Pros:
✅ Natural and eco-friendly material
✅ Great sensory experience
✅ Easy to grip and chew
❄️ 3. Nuby Ice Gel Teether Keys — Best for Cooling Relief
This colorful key-shaped teether can be chilled in the refrigerator (not frozen) for a soothing effect. It features multiple textures to massage gums and promote fine motor skills.
Pros:
✅ Cooling gel provides extra comfort
✅ Easy to hold and chew
✅ Affordable and widely available
Safety Note: Only chill in the fridge, not freezer, to prevent over-hardening.
🌱 4. Green Sprouts Cool Ring — Best Budget Pick
If you’re looking for a simple, low-cost, and safe teething ring, the Green Sprouts Cool Ring is a parent favorite. It’s designed to be cooled in the fridge and is free from BPA, PVC, and phthalates.
Pros:
✅ Budget-friendly
✅ Chillable and soothing
✅ Lightweight and travel-friendly
🦷 5. Ark Grabber — Best for Strong Chewers
For babies who love to bite everything, the Ark Grabber offers firm resistance and a safe shape that helps develop oral motor skills. Its ergonomic “handle” design prevents choking and promotes jaw strength.
Pros:
✅ Built for aggressive chewers
✅ Encourages jaw muscle development
✅ Available in multiple resistance levels
🧼 Safety Tips for Choosing Teething Toys
Keeping your baby safe is priority number one. Here’s what to look for:
- Choose BPA-free, phthalate-free, and non-toxic materials
- Avoid gel-filled teethers — they can leak or harbor bacteria
- Check for one-piece construction to prevent choking hazards
- Supervise your baby while teething or chewing any toy
🩺 According to the American Academy of Pediatrics, chilled teethers and gentle gum massage are the safest ways to relieve teething pain.
🧽 Cleaning & Care Tips
- Wash silicone teethers with warm, soapy water or in the dishwasher (top rack).
- For natural rubber teethers, gently wipe with a damp cloth — avoid boiling.
- Always inspect for cracks, tears, or leaks and replace immediately.
- Store in a clean, dry container after each use.
🛒 How to Choose the Right Teether by Age
0–4 Months:
Soft silicone rings or small shapes easy to grip.
4–8 Months:
Textured teethers that stimulate gums and encourage self-feeding coordination.
8–12+ Months:
More durable teethers designed for stronger chewing, like Ark Grabber or freezer-safe models.
🗣️ FAQ — Common Questions About Teething Toys
Q: Are teething toys safe for newborns?
A: Yes, as long as they’re designed for infants and made from non-toxic, BPA-free materials. Always supervise playtime.
Q: Can I freeze teething toys?
A: Only if the manufacturer allows. Many teethers are best chilled in the fridge instead of frozen to prevent gum injury.
Q: Silicone or rubber — which is better?
A: Both are excellent when safe and certified. Silicone is easier to clean, while natural rubber feels softer and more eco-friendly.
Q: How many teething toys should I have?
A: Most parents keep 2–3 different textures on hand — one chilled, one firm, and one soft.
💬 Final Thoughts
Every baby’s teething journey is unique. Whether you prefer a classic natural rubber like Sophie la Girafe or a modern silicone design like Comotomo, the key is choosing something safe, soothing, and easy to clean.
Rotate between different textures, chill a few in the fridge, and let your baby explore — teething comfort (and smiles) are just a chew away!
Affiliate Disclaimer: As an Amazon Associate, we may earn from qualifying purchases.
Read More:
- Best Educational Toys for BabiesDiscover the best educational toys for babies that boost learning, creativity, and development through fun, sensory-rich, and age-appropriate play experiences.
- Best Bath Toys for ToddlersDiscover the best bath toys for toddlers that make bath time fun, safe, and educational while encouraging creativity, motor skills, and sensory learning.
- How to Choose the Best Baby Rattles for Your BabyDiscover how to choose the best baby rattles that are safe, engaging, and perfect for your baby’s developmental milestones.
- Best Pop Up Toys for Babies: A Fun Way to Boost Early LearningExplore the best pop up toys for babies that make learning fun while boosting motor skills and curiosity.
- Stacking and Sorting Toys for Kids with AutismExplore the best sorting toys for kids with autism that make learning fun, sensory-friendly, and skill-building through joyful play.
